Scariest/freakiest part of the game?

[mrpaku]

If not the mirror room, I'd go with the mannequin room. That girl's scream is just terrifying the first time you hear it, and then you walk back around the corner and that headless manequin is bleeding...one of the people I was playing this with and trying to explain Silent Hill too, after regaining her composure asked, "Wait, does that mean someone died in the real world?"
*shiver*