Scariest/freakiest part of the game?

[Spider]

I thought the haunted house in the amusement park was pretty freaky. It made me and my dad jump a few times  . The killer red light fog made me panic.

I hate that fog. I really hate it.

The dead guy dropping down in the haunted house scared my wife to no end.

Whenever I play a new Silent Hill she wants to "play" it with me. She loves the games but just doesn't want to control the character. So I will be strolling along, getting info and killing a few enemies when something like the cat in the locker room from V.1 will happen. She will scream like mad, which I for some reason never expect (probably too engrossed within the game) and she makes me lose the controller.

I have lost more boss fights that way....