The Official Silent Hill 2 Ending

[Lobsel_Vith]

There's been a lot of debate over the official ending of Silent Hill 2. Most say it's the In Water ending because in SH4 Henry makes a comment that Frank Sunderland's son (James) and daughter in-law disappeared and never returned. However it's doubtful that James would have gone back to his hometown no matter what the ending might have been, so that brings this up.

Also there's a huge wall followed a hill with alot of trees. I'm not saying the In Water ending is wrong...