The Official Silent Hill 2 Ending

[shootzombies]

I also believe that the "In-water" ending is the official ending of SH2 because in SH4, Frank Sunderland says that his son had disappeared, which could potentially mean that he had been missing since the events of SH2. But then again, how do we know that James didn't have any siblings? Nobody has ever really thought about that before. There really is no evidence that says that James was an only child. Maybe James has a brother, whom they never mentioned in SH2. Perhaps he will appear as the protagonist of a future Silent Hill game- maybe investigating the disappearance of his brother?